DFA to replace Unfair Commercial Practices Directive, regulating matters such as dark patterns, influencers, and addictive design
Don’t miss our content
SubscribeThe European Commission (“the Commission”) presented its long-awaited proposal for a Digital Fairness Act (“DFA”), together with its annexes, on November 11, 2026. The proposal takes the form of a regulation that would repeal and replace the 2005 Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (Directive 2005/29/EC), adding a new chapter on digital fairness.
The DFA is part of a larger package of consumer protection proposals that the Commission has presented together. It has presented a Simplification Directive that would amend Directive 2011/83/EU, on consumer rights, and Directive 2002/58/EC on privacy and electronic communications. It has also proposed a revision of Regulation (EU) 2017/2394, on cooperation regarding consumer protection (“CPC Regulation”).
Below we discuss the main aspects of the proposal for a DFA.
I. From Directive to Regulation
The proposal entails replacing the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (“UCPD”) with a regulation, i.e., with an instrument that is directly applicable, which would mean replacing the 27 national transposing regimes and, thus, reducing the scope for divergent national interpretations. The recitals of the proposal specify that the change in itself does not alter the level of harmonization, because the UCPD already provided for full harmonization. The change from a directive to a regulation would have a second consequence: it would make it possible to grant powers to the Commission to directly investigate and penalize certain infringements, in line with the new CPC Regulation proposed (recital 5).
The DFA proposal maintains the substantive content of the UCPD: the general clause, misleading actions and omissions, aggressive practices, and the list in annex I of practices regarded as unfair in all circumstances (articles 5 through 9, and annex I). According to the correlation table in annex II, points 11, 12, 14, 33 and 34 of annex I, and the new part III (points 53 through 62), do not have an equivalent in the UCPD: they refer to price comparisons, prices excluding all unavoidable charges, offers for limited periods without indicating the duration, drop shipping and dark patterns. The proposal also maintains the two exceptions to full harmonization already provided for in the UCPD. In this way, the Member States can continue to impose more restrictive requirements for financial services and immovable property (article 2.8). Member States will also be able to adopt their own rules regarding unsolicited visits to a consumer’s home and commercial excursions (article 2.4).
According to the preamble, the definitions in article 3 have been adapted to Court of Justice of the European Union case law. The notion of “transactional decision” now includes the decision to continue using a product (article 3.6). Recital 22 indicates that the delivery of personal data can be considered “payment.” Article 5.4.c) expressly qualifies as unfair all practices breaching the obligations laid down in Chapter III, focusing on digital fairness.
II. Dark patterns
Article 10.1 of the proposal for the DFA prohibits traders from designing, organizing or operating their online interfaces, including their visual and auditory components, in a way that may deceive or manipulate consumers. It also prohibits traders from doing so in any other way that could materially distort consumers’ economic behavior.
Added to this general rule is a list of dark patterns that will be considered unfair in all circumstances, included in a new part III of annex I (article 10.2). The Commission may amend or expand this list through delegated acts (article 10.3).
Under part III of annex I, there are 10 dark patterns (points 53 through 62): false claims about the availability or the popularity of a product, or the lack of relevant clarification on this point; persistently displaying statements throughout the ordering process about the availability or popularity of a product to create an impression of scarcity; default options which the consumer is required to reject to avoid paying for an additional product, a different quantity of the product or a different product; presenting the option to decline an invitation to purchase or to continue the supply of a product as the wrong choice; creating the false impression that there is no other option apart from the prominently featured option; persistently requesting that consumers make a choice or change their choice where that choice has already been made, where this is not necessary to comply with legal requirements; using misleading or ambiguous language in the presentation of choices to consumers, including double negatives; presenting the price or information about the duration of the contract and its automatic renewal in an invitation to purchase with less prominence than other items of material information; sending false consumer notifications; and making the steps required to refuse, withdraw or change a choice disproportionately more numerous, complex or time-consuming than is reasonably necessary.
III. Influencers
The proposal defines influencer marketing as a commercial practice (article 3.15). Article 11.1 requires the commercial intent of all communications to be clear, prominent and unambiguous, through the terms “advertisement” or “commercial collaboration.” If the communication is published on an online platform subject to the Digital Services Act (the “DSA”), disclosure should be made using the functionality provided for in article 26.2 DSA (article 11.2).
Article 11.3 prohibits traders carrying out influencer marketing from including direct exhortations to minors to buy products or to convince their parents or other adults to buy them, create the impression that they are not acting for commercial purposes, and create the impression that a product is appropriate for minors when it is not. They also cannot promote products whose advertisement is prohibited by EU or national law, or dangerous products (articles 11.4 and 11.5).
The proposal also imposes obligations on other traders in the influencer marketing chain. Traders that hire influencer marketing services, e.g., the brand or the advertising agency, must ensure, contractually or by other appropriate means, that the influencer complies with the regulation (article 11.6).
IV. Personalized advertising and pricing
Article 12 prohibits traders from targeting advertisements to consumers based on profiling (as defined in article 4.4 General Data Protection Regulation or GDPR) in two scenarios. The first is when the trader is aware with reasonable certainty that the consumer is a minor. The second scenario is when it uses special categories of personal data referred to in article 9.1 GDPR.
According to the preamble, article 12 extends prohibitions that the DSA already imposes on online platforms to other traders. Article 12.1 does not apply to providers of online platforms subject to section 3, chapter III, DSA. Recital 59 adds that the prohibition also extends to personalized content suggestions, product rankings and recommendations, including in natural language systems.
Article 13 prohibits personalizing prices based on profiling in a way that could reasonably cause harm to consumers. The prohibition is applied when the trader knows with reasonable certainty that the consumer is a minor or is vulnerable based on age, credulity or disability, or any misfortune or circumstance of such gravity that affects the consumer’s judgment. According to recital 60, this does not extend to personalization that benefits the consumer, such as discounts for students or the elderly.
Neither of these articles obliges traders to process additional personal data to ascertain whether the consumer is a minor or is vulnerable.
V. Virtual currencies, loot boxes and addictive design
Articles 14 through 16 govern practices the proposal calls spending-maximizing. Several rules apply when the product is aimed at minors or when the trader knows with reasonable certainty that minors use it. Thus, in the case of paid-for virtual currencies (article 14), traders must indicate the actual or estimated monetary value of what is purchased with them. In those cases, these currencies must be disabled by default for minors and can only be activated with parent or guardian approval. Regarding paid variable reward systems (article 15), e.g., loot boxes, traders must inform consumers of the types of virtual products or objects available and of the probability of obtaining them and offer all consumers tools to disable them. Traders cannot offer them to minors. Finally, pay-to-win and pay-to-progress mechanisms (article 16) cannot be offered to minors.
Article 17 governs addictive design. It affects traders that design, organize or operate their digital products with the purpose of encouraging compulsive or excessive use, or in a way that is likely to encourage such use. Those traders must make available effective and easy-to-access tools to disable, individually or all at once, four features: (a) automatic play of content and uninterrupted content consumption without effective and regular interruption moments; (b) notifications not triggered by, or not directly related to, the consumer’s activity on the service; (c) features incentivizing engagement at regular times, including through penalties for not doing so; (d) simulation of interpersonal relations, such as persistent prompts to continue engaging with an automated system.
The Commission may amend this list through delegated acts (article 17.2). Some of these rules exclude the providers subject to certain provisions of the EU KIDS Act proposal (articles 14.1, 15.3 and 17.1).
VI. Price transparency
Article 18 handles event tickets. If the price can increase due to the trader’s actions or due to automated or algorithmic processes, the invitation to buy must indicate how many tickets are available at the price advertised for that category and the maximum price a consumer may have to pay for that ticket. A trader offering resale of tickets must display the original total price of the ticket charged by the organizer and, where applicable, the ticket category, row and seat number.
Article 19 governs virtual queues. While the consumer is waiting, the trader must display the current price, updated in real time if the price varies, and indicate whether that price can vary during the waiting time and, in that case, indicate the maximum price.
In addition, annex I includes, among the unfair practices in all circumstances, comparisons with a reference price that is not the current price of a clearly identified competitor (point 11) and drip pricing, i.e., not including in the first price displayed all the foreseeable charges that the consumer will unavoidably have to pay (point 12). Recitals 105 and 106 explain both prohibitions.
VII. Digital contracts and automated agents
Articles 20 through 28 of the proposal govern different aspects of digital contracts and commercial communications:
- Free trial periods (article 20): before the trial period ends, the trader must send a reminder, and conversion to a contract on a paid basis requires the consumer’s express acceptance. If any of these two aspects are not present, the consumer will not be bound.
- Automatic extension (articles 21 and 22): for contracts for the continuous supply of products concluded by digital means, with a duration of six months or longer, the reminder must be sent between one month and 14 days before the extension. For shorter contracts, it must be no later than one week before the extension which results in the contract duration reaching six months or constitutes the 10th extension, except for certain investment contracts. If there is no reminder, the consumer can terminate the contract free of charge and without notice. If the contract has been extended indefinitely, it can be terminated at any time with a maximum one month’s notice.
- Online contract termination function (article 23): if the trader allows contracts to be concluded through an online interface, it must offer a function on the interface with the wording “terminate the contract here” or equivalent wording and include a confirmation step and an acknowledgment of receipt on a durable medium. Article 24 provides for a similar function to exercise the right of withdrawal online.
- Customer service with a human being (article 25): if the trader provides online customer service after the conclusion of a contract, the consumer may request to communicate with a human being when other means are not effective, except in the case of investment services.
- Automated systems for contracting (article 26): on the first use, consumers must choose whether they want to confirm all, only some, or none of the contracts proposed by the system. The system must disclose the payments received by the trader making the system available to the consumer for proposing a contract, and any relevant conflicts of interest and, in that case, must request confirmation. Traders cannot require the use of these systems to access their interfaces or to conclude commercial transactions (article 26.9) This article does not apply to financial services (article 26.10).
- Unsolicited commercial communications (article 28): the regulation incorporates the rules of Directive 2002/58/EC on unsolicited communications for direct sales purposes (calls, email, SMS and MMS).
VIII. Application, evidence and penalties
Article 29 contains an “anti-circumvention” clause: it prohibits any conduct, whether contractual, commercial, technical or related to the interface design, that undermines compliance with the obligations in chapter III.
Chapter IV contains provisions on application of the regulation:
- The Commission may investigate and impose penalties, in areas not expressly excluded, for widespread infringements with a European Union dimension, in line with the new CPC Regulation proposed in parallel (article 30.4). It may impose fines up to a maximum of 6% of the trader’s worldwide annual turnover (article 35.6).
- In the case of national authorities, in coordinated actions, the maximum amount of fines should be at least 4% of the trader's annual turnover in the affected Member States. If this data is not available, the maximum should be at least €2 million (articles 35.3 and 35.4).
- Regarding evidence, if the plaintiff requests it and provides sufficient indications of an unfair online practice, or the authority has a reasonable suspicion, the courts and the authorities may require the trader to produce evidence regarding the design, operation and impact of the practice on consumers. If the trader does not produce this evidence, this fact may be taken into account, together with other evidence, to assess the unfairness (article 34).
- The remedies available for the consumer are compensation for damage and, where applicable, price reduction or contract termination (article 32).
- A right of recourse is established: a trader declared liable for an unfair online commercial practice may bring proceedings against the persons with which it has a commercial relationship and whose actions or omissions have caused or contributed to the infringement (article 36).
IX. Next steps
The proposal for a DFA must now be debated by the European Parliament and the Council, following the ordinary legislative procedure. According to article 40 of the proposal, the DFA would enter into force 20 days after its publication in the Official Journal of the European Union and would apply 12 months after its entry into force. The Commission must assess it at the latest 60 months after its date of application (article 39).
On our blog we will follow the proposal’s development closely.
Don’t miss our content
Subscribe